HearingAssist Control vs Starkey Evolv AI

The HearingAssist Control is a behind-the-ear OTC hearing aid priced at $549, earning a B grade with a SoundScore of 3.3/5 in our lab testing. This places it in the lower portion of the OTC category, ranking #51 of 65 devices tested. In our testing, the Control demonstrates notable strengths in speech performance. Speech in quiet scores 0.59 points above the category average at 3.4/5, representing solid absolute performance. Speech in noise comes in at 2.0/5—above the category average by 0.56 points, though only mixed in absolute terms. Feedback handling is excellent at 5.0/5, meaning the device remained stable without audible squealing during our standardized challenge tests. The device shows significant weaknesses in other areas. Music streaming scored 0.0/5, which is 1.92 points below the category average and indicates this device does not support or perform well with phone audio streaming. Own-voice comfort is also below average at 2.1/5 (0.41 points below category average), which may be noticeable during extended conversations. The HearingAssist Control may suit users who prioritize speech clarity over streaming functionality and who don't require premium sound quality across all use cases. However, buyers in this price range should note that several competitors—including the Yeasound RIC800 and Sony CRE-E10—deliver substantially higher overall scores. Those seeking similar speech performance at a lower cost may also consider the iHear MatriX.

The Starkey Evolv AI is a premium behind-the-ear prescription hearing aid released in 2022, currently available at $4,598. In HearAdvisor's lab testing, it earned a B grade with a SoundScore of 3.9/5, ranking #28 of 36 prescription hearing aids tested. This device shows notable strengths in specific performance areas. Music streaming quality stands out at 3.7/5, scoring 1.06 points above the category average—making it a solid choice for users who prioritize audio entertainment. Speech in noise performance reaches 2.8/5, which is 0.81 points above the category average, though the absolute score reflects mixed real-world performance in challenging listening environments. Speech in quiet is solid at 3.4/5, slightly above average. The Evolv AI does show weaknesses in two key areas. Own voice comfort scores 2.1/5, falling 0.65 points below the category average, which may affect how natural your own speech sounds. Feedback handling, while solid in absolute terms at 3.5/5, runs 1.21 points below the category average of 4.71/5—meaning competitors in this price tier generally offer better feedback suppression. At this premium price point, several alternatives deliver stronger overall performance, including the Phonak Sphere Infinio and Oticon Intent. However, the Evolv AI's Expert's Choice Award recognition in 2023 and 2024 reflects its practical strengths. This hearing aid may suit users who prioritize music streaming quality and improved speech understanding in noise over own-voice comfort, and who value Starkey's feature set including rechargeable batteries and hands-free calling for both iPhone and Android.